Old Northside is a 36-square-block neighborhood north of downtown, bounded by 16th Street, Bellefontaine Street, I-65 and Pennsylvania Street. It began as two communities. In the 1850s, Ovid Butler gave a campus for North Western Christian University, later Butler University, near 13th Street and College Avenue, and a small town called College Corner grew around it. The other part grew out of the wealthy homes north of the Mile Square along Meridian Street.
Houses went up here from 1870 to 1914 in Gothic Revival, Italianate, Second Empire, Queen Anne, Eastlake and Stick styles. President Benjamin Harrison lived in the neighborhood, and so did authors Booth Tarkington and Meredith Nicholson. Families moved north after World War I, and during World War II many large homes were divided into apartments and rooming houses. A few owners began restoring homes in the early 1970s and founded Old Northside, Inc., in 1975. The district joined the National Register of Historic Places in 1978, and the Indianapolis Historic Preservation Commission made it a local historic district that same year. By 1993, about 80 percent of the housing had been renovated.
These are houses with rooflines that take work to keep tight. Second Empire homes are known for their mansard roofs, and Queen Anne homes for towers, bays and steep slopes that meet in many valleys. Each of those meeting points needs good flashing, and a small leak can run along framing for a long way before it shows. When we repair a house like this, we usually start with the flashing, the trim at the roof's edge and the chimney.
The neighborhood's land use committee reviews historic commission applications for residents and helps them through the process, so ask it before a repair changes the look of the roof. The Old Northside Foundation also raises money for new trees, street lamps and parks, and Great Oak Commons is a small park with a fountain. The drive from our office to Old Northside takes about 15 minutes.